Historic restoration revives beloved La Grange Stone Avenue Train Station
By Marc Rohde and Douglas Ogurek
Images courtesy of Legat Architects.
Tom Livingston, president of the Village of La Grange, Ill., reflects with fondness on the Stone Avenue Train Station. “My father took the train out of this station for forty years. It’s a real workhorse,” he said.
However, time had taken a toll on the century-old station: rusted gutters, rotting wood, peeling paint, a deteriorated roof. The workhorse needed mending.
In 2005, the village launched a restoration effort that would truly “take a village” to pull off. It would require the input of a wide range of resources, ranging from village officials to legislators, railroad representatives, and community organizations.
On a warm October morning last fall, Livingston and the La Grange community celebrated the project’s completion. The 900-square-foot station, with its locally quarried limestone and bold arches, now gleams with as much charisma as it did when it was built in 1901.
|Masonry arches and built-in seating add to the train station’s allure.|
Worthy of a railroad suburb
La Grange has long been a railroad community. Railroad service began as early as 1864 and by 1869, commuter rail service connected the village to nearby Chicago. In 1870, Franklin D. Cossitt purchased 600 acres of land adjacent to the railroad. Nine years later, the Village of La Grange was incorporated.
The Stone Avenue Train Station exemplifies both the Classical and Richardsonian Romanesque styles. Heavy, rusticated stone arches, gabled roofs, and wood dentil detailing define the station. The limestone of the outer gallery walls likely was sourced from a local quarry. The La Grange Area Historical Society designated the station a local landmark in 1971.
Over the years, the station endured several renovations, which replaced many of the original features with less-than-historic versions.
When the latest restoration project was undertaken, the design team had to contend with recreating the turn-of-the-century feel within limited budget parameters, while also respecting ongoing maintenance requirements. Marc Rohde, director of municipal architecture at Legat Architects said, “Generic globe lighting on the outside and fluorescent ceiling lights on the inside detracted from the authenticity of the architecture.”
Rohde has mourned many train stations damaged by decades of commuter traffic and harsh Chicago winters. “The Stone Avenue Station is a historic landmark that had taken a real hit. When I first inspected it, I saw beat-up asphalt shingles on the roof, gaps in the limestone, and beadboard that was gray and peeling.”
|Early 20th century image of the train station.|
The village secured funding for the anticipated $1,085,000 project through two primary grant sources: Congressman Dan Lipinski ($700,000 grant) and the West Suburban Mass Transit District ($385,000 grant). The project was competitively bid and awarded to Boller Construction of Waukegan in 2013.
Rep. Lipinski (D-IL 3rd District) had seen old stations demolished, then replaced by new stations that looked similar to the old ones. He said, “The Stone Avenue station is a cherished part of the La Grange community and I didn’t want it to meet a similar fate.”
The way it should be
To help research and reignite the station’s historic charm, the village and Legat Architects enlisted the assistance of the La Grange Area Historical Society. “The society uncovered the station’s original 1901 plans, which were used to help guide the renovation design,” said Assistant Village Manager Andrianna Peterson. “The team also studied the society’s collection of early postcards and photographs of the station’s historic features.”
The unearthed documentation influenced material and fixture selection, including the identification of period-correct light fixtures outside and new chandeliers inside. Additionally, the team replaced plain aluminum doors with aluminum-framed oak doors and repainted with historically accurate colors.
“The project focused on preserving the look and feel of many of the station’s beautiful historic features,” said Rohde. “For instance, the restoration fixed the rotting dentil molding along the roofline and replaced the old beadboard on the outdoor ceilings with stained oak beadboard.”
Designers also had to be respectful of the village’s budget and maintenance constraints. There was a careful balance between choosing affordable, contemporary materials and creating authenticity. For instance, 100-percent recyclable and durable polymeric slate roof tiles replace the damaged asphalt shingles. The new tiles are a cost-effective alternative to traditional slate and require much less maintenance.
The tiles also are aesthetically appealing. “When you look at the roof,” said Rohde, “you see subtle color changes based on your perspective and the position of the sun.”
The project scope also addressed historic platform signage. Legat used the 1901 station plans to recreate the design of the original carved wood and metal platform sign.
Additional repairs included landscape improvements (design courtesy of the La Grange Garden Club and Hitchcock Design Group) to make the station more inviting with beautiful, yet accessible outdoor spaces.
|Among the improvements to the station are tuck-pointed limestone and restored dentil molding, as well as new gutters and stained oak beadboard.|
A community constant
The Village of La Grange has a long-standing tradition of preserving its past. Turn-of-the-century homes in many styles enrich its large historic district. The thriving downtown includes a tapestry of buildings dating from the late 1800s.
In the last century, the village has transformed from a quaint shopping town to what Livingston calls “a transit-oriented, vibrant downtown.” Indeed, the village has been fortunate to receive several recent accolades, including one of the “Best Places to Live” and “Best Downtown” by Chicago magazine and “Top Transit Suburb” by the De Paul Chaddick Institute.
La Grange residents continue to embrace the iconic Stone Avenue Train Station; it serves nearly 1,000 commuters each day. “Everyone keeps saying how beautiful it is,” said Andrea Barnish, resident and chairman of the Design Review Commission, which was consulted on the station’s upgrade. “It’s nice to see it was restored and not replaced.”
Curtis Linder, resident and treasurer of the West Suburban Mass Transit District said, “It’s a dramatic improvement to an architectural gem.”
The workhorse is back on track.
Marc Rohde, AIA LEED AP, is director of municipal architecture at Legat Architects.
Douglas Ogurek, LEED AP BD+C, is communications manager at Legat Architects.
- 73CLICK HERE TO GO TOTHE DIGITAL EDITION Spring 2015: Table of Contents featuresMaterialsBrick: An Old Way to a Better Tomorrow Since early mankind moved out of caves and into communities, brick was a desired construction material. With readily available raw materials, a simple manufacturing process, and durable and sustainable results,…
- 35The New York City architectural and planning firm of Urbahn Architects has completed the renovation of the historic Morgan Avenue subway station house for the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA). Serving the L train line, the Morgan Avenue station house is located on the west side of Bogart Street, at the…
- 35JulyAugust 2008:Table of Contentsfeatures Design TrendsChateaux on Central A splendid, brick-clad residential building rises in Phoenix.By Cory Sekine-PettiteMaterialsAs Cast Stone Prices Fall, Will Quality Suffer? Specify concrete with a conscienceBy Fred McGeeSpotlightAn Academic Approach Atkinson-Noland & Associates, Inc. has spent more than 20 years cultivating a practice focused on structural evaluation…