Vibing Masonry #8: CMU’s Durability and Maintenance Value

Words: Steve Blye
Photos: weninchina.com, Masonry Industry Promotion Group, Structure Magazine, Structure Magazine, housedigest.com, fortworthdrywallcontractor.com, crashofrhinospainting.com, Oldcastle, powerhousehcs.com, InspectApedia.com, diychatroom.com

Heading to Spokane, WA, I found myself riding the airport tram at O’Hare in Chicago. Looking out the window at a part of the 26-year-old International Terminal 5, I spotted a painted structural steel beam in front of a concrete masonry unit (CMU) wall. The painted steel had succumbed to severe corrosion—rust blossoming like fungus through stained, peeling paint. Yet, the CMU wall behind it was nearly pristine, appearing almost new despite the decades.

A similar memory surfaced from years earlier. A fellow architect had designed an intricate painted steel grillwork for a parking structure, winning an AIA design award. Ten years later, when I parked there, the once-celebrated sculpture was failing—rusted joints, peeling paint, stained concrete below. Yet the surrounding concrete block walls needed only light cleaning and fresh paint.

CMU vs. Other Exterior Systems: Durability by Design
Concrete masonry units are a proven, low-maintenance solution for educational, municipal, institutional, public, and many other building types. Combined with modern innovations—integral water repellents and even emerging self-healing technologies—CMU walls resist weathering, staining, and fire better than wood siding, cement-board panels, metal composite panels, or most other finishes. Over a 10 to 50-year building lifespan, these properties translate directly into lower costs and fewer maintenance repairs.

The Self-Healing Exploration: From Ancient Rome to the Autobahn
Roman concrete formed the 1,900-year-old Pantheon dome and used hot-mix technology that incorporated lime clasts that would reseal cracks when exposed to water. This auto-healing phenomenon allowed the structure to endure two millennia. Inspired by this history, German researchers are embedding dormant Bacillus bacteria or mineral capsules into concrete slabs on test sections of the Autobahn. When cracks admit moisture, the bacteria activate and produce limestone, sealing fissures up to 0.8 mm and extending service life by up to 40%. Today’s concrete masonry manufacturers are exploring similar microcapsules, bacterial agents, and crystalline admixtures, setting the stage for self-maintaining walls that require minimal intervention over an extended time.

Construction Practices That Ensure Longevity
CMU assemblies often incorporate integral silane/siloxane water repellents during the manufacture of both block and mortar. These treatments lower absorption, resist freeze-thaw damage, and inhibit mold or staining. Architectural CMU finishes, ground-face or polished, maintain their appearance with only routine cleaning. Unlike coatings on steel or wood, these repellents do not require reapplication, although additional spray-on protection can also be considered.

For institutional projects expected to last 50 years or more, proper detailing is critical:

Foundations: CMU walls should rest on reinforced concrete footings with proper drainage and vapor barriers.
Reinforcement: Steel-reinforced bond beams and masonry lintels distribute loads and limit cracking, replacing the need for complicated structural steel beams in many designs. These CMU masonry lintels have spanned 70-80 feet over theater stage openings and more.
Movement joints: Control-joint systems and vertical reinforcement accommodate thermal and minimal seismic movement.
Moisture control: Through-wall flashing, sealants at penetrations, and repellent-modified mortar reduce water intrusion.
Finish care: Pressure washing every 5–10 years (at 1,500–3,000 psi) costs only $0.10–$0.30/sq. ft., and repainting cycles run 10–15 years—far longer than wood or metal systems.

Fire Performance: Material Comparison

Wood siding: Fails structurally around 570–750 °F.
Cement-board panels: Lose stability above 750–1,100 °F.
Metal panels: Soften around 1,100 °F.
Painted steel: Requires intumescent coatings to resist beyond 1,800 °F.
CMU: Remains non-combustible and structurally sound above 1,800 °F.

This inherent fire resistance is one reason CMU is widely specified for schools, hospitals, and public safety buildings.

Lifecycle Costs: CMU vs. Alternative Exterior Cladding

Installed costs for exterior CMU walls typically run $15–20/sq. ft. (painted up to $25/sq. ft., ground-face $18–25/sq. ft.). Over 50 years, maintenance is minimal—pressure washing, tuckpointing, occasional repainting—totaling roughly $2–5/sq. ft. By contrast:

Wood siding: $7–14/sq. ft. installed; full repainting every 3–5 years; often replaced entirely within 30–40 years.
Cement board panels: $16–26/sq. ft. installed; replacement likely once in 50 years.
Painted steel or metal panels: $30–45/sq. ft. installed; corrosion monitoring and repaint cycles required, with eventual replacement.

Over a half-century, CMU consistently outperforms these systems in both cost and durability, making it the value leader for public facilities.

CMU Inside Buildings: An Alternative to Drywall
While drywall dominates most interior partitions, many schools, municipal buildings, and public facilities are turning to CMU for interior walls—especially in high-traffic zones like gyms, corridors, and restrooms. The choice raises several comparisons:

Durability & Impact Resistance: CMU resists dents, gouges, and abrasion—ideal for spaces subject to carts, sports equipment, or vandalism. Drywall is inexpensive initially but easily punctured, requiring frequent repairs.

Maintenance & Lifecycle Cost: CMU requires minimal upkeep: occasional repainting and cleaning. Drywall repairs accumulate—patching holes, repainting after moisture damage, replacing sections after impacts—raising total cost over decades.

Lifespan: CMU interior partitions can last the life of the building, often exceeding 50–75 years. Drywall partitions rarely exceed 20–30 years without significant renovation.

Flexibility in Renovation: Drywall is easier to remove or reconfigure; CMU is more permanent, but non-structural CMU can be easily removed and reconfigured for new layouts.

Safety & Fire Resistance: CMU partitions are inherently fireproof and add acoustic mass, providing better sound isolation and safer egress routes. Drywall assemblies rely on fire-rated layers that can be compromised if damaged. A four-hour rated drywall assembly will still fail far sooner than a 4-hour CMU wall.

Moisture Resistance: CMU is unaffected by leaks or flooding, making it ideal for basements, locker rooms, and restrooms when allowed to dry properly. Drywall swells, molds, and deteriorates rapidly when wet.

Structural: CMU is often specified in many buildings for stair and elevator enclosure, shear walls, and foundations. Since it is already being used on many jobsites, consider using CMU to replace other structural systems.

For public facilities where vandal resistance, sanitation, moisture management, and longevity are priorities, CMU interiors often prove cost-effective despite higher initial expense.

Conclusion

Aesthetics and Cleanability: Ground or polished CMUs resist fading and have inherent beauty (see beautyofblock.com); painted units are easily refreshed.
Structural Integrity and Fire or Impact Resistance: Properly reinforced CMU walls stay intact for generations, remaining superior to wood, steel, or drywall alternatives.
Innovations in Self-Healing: Bacterial admixtures and crystalline agents promise even lower maintenance in the future.

CMU provides predictable durability and low maintenance. Exterior walls built of block routinely outlast competing systems by decades, and in high-abuse interiors, CMU partitions outperform drywall in safety and lifecycle cost. For long-lived institutional and municipal facilities—schools, airports, public safety buildings—invest in CMU, detail it properly, and enjoy walls that endure with minimal care for half a century or more.

Vibing Masonry #8: CMU’s Durability and Maintenance Value

About: Technical Talks

Keeping it Clean: Lifecycle Maintenance for Manufactured Stone Veneer

MCAA's Wall Evaluator: The Future of Masonry Training and Assessment

Government Affairs: Dignity Act Is Back and So Are Our Marching Orders!

Marvelous Masonry: Inveraray Castle